The Loan Estimate lands in your inbox, you scroll to the bottom, and the closing costs are thousands of dollars higher than anyone mentioned. That reaction is common, and it is usually fixable. I’m Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647, and I review Loan Estimates daily. Almost none of them are a single block of fixed charges. Duane Buziak breaks them into lines that can be negotiated, lines that can be shopped, and lines that can be restructured with credits, points, or financing. Each of the seven strategies below targets one of those types instead of telling you to cut everything. They run from quickest to deepest, so the first two can be done this week, and the last few depend on how long you plan to keep the loan.
1. Read the Loan Estimate line by line
The Loan Estimate is the standardized three-page form you receive within three business days of applying. Its closing cost detail is split into sections. Section A is origination charges, which are the fees for making the loan. Section B is services you cannot shop for. Section C is services you can shop for, such as title and settlement. Sections E through H cover taxes, prepaids, and escrow. Section J totals the costs after any lender credits.
Imagine a borrower who finds a $795 processing fee, a $995 underwriting fee, and a $310 document preparation fee in Section A, $2,100 in total. Asking which of those overlap is a fair question, because some companies fold all three into one charge and others itemize them.
- Get the Loan Estimate and mark each line as lender-controlled (Section A), shoppable (Section C), or third-party fixed (government fees, prepaid interest, taxes).
- Ask for a written explanation of every fee over $300.
- Ask the broker directly which Section A fees are negotiable or can be removed.
The most common mistake is comparing only the interest rate. A quote with a lower rate and $2,000 more in Section A can cost you more for years. Measure the total of Sections A, B, and C against a second quote, and count how many fees were removed or reduced after you asked.
2. Shop many lenders through a broker with a soft pull
A broker submits one file to many wholesale lenders, so the competition happens on the lenders’ side while you provide your information once. Pricing on the same loan can differ meaningfully between them. A single-company channel such as Rocket or Movement is worth pulling as a benchmark, but it can only show you that company’s own pricing. Virginia mortgage brokers are licensed through the State Corporation Commission’s Bureau of Financial Institutions, so confirm any broker’s license and NMLS number before you share documents.
Suppose three quotes on the same $350,000 loan look like this:
- Quote 1: 6.375% with $3,900 in Section A.
- Quote 2: 6.375% with $2,100 in Section A.
- Quote 3: 6.50% with $2,400 in Section A.
Quotes 1 and 2 carry the same rate, so Quote 2 saves $1,800 outright. Quote 3 looks cheap in Section A, but its rate adds roughly $29 a month. Over seven years that is about $2,400, more than the origination savings.
How to run the comparison
- Complete a No Touch Credit pre-qualification. This is a soft credit pull mortgage review, so it is a no credit hit mortgage application, and you get a no hard inquiry mortgage pre approval to work from.
- Request quotes on identical loan terms, points, and lock timing.
- Line the Loan Estimates up side by side.
The pitfall is comparing quotes that differ in points, credits, or lock period, which makes the numbers meaningless. Judge each quote by total cost over the years you expect to own the home, not by rate alone.
3. Shop and swap Section C services
Section C lists services you are allowed to shop for, usually title search, title insurance, settlement or closing agent, and sometimes a survey. The lender provides a list of providers, but you can choose your own. Because these are independent businesses, their fees vary even for identical files.
For example, imagine your Loan Estimate lists a settlement agent at $1,150 and a local provider you call quotes $700 for the same work. Switching saves $450 and costs one email.
This is where tolerance buckets matter. Tolerance is the cap on how much a fee can rise between the Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure, the final five-page statement you receive at least three business days before closing. The CFPB explains the rules, but in short:
- Lender fees and the services you cannot shop for cannot increase.
- Recording fees and listed providers you use can rise by no more than 10% in total.
- Providers you pick from outside the list carry no cap, though a good provider will still quote you a firm number.
The steps:
- Read the provider list on your Loan Estimate.
- Call two or three providers with the same file details.
- Get written quotes that include every fee.
- Tell your broker in writing which provider you chose.
The mistake is picking an off-list provider with a lower headline price and then watching their added fees land with no cap. Measure the dollar difference in Section C and confirm the figure did not rise on the Closing Disclosure.
4. Negotiate seller concessions
A seller concession is money the seller agrees to put toward your closing costs, written into the purchase contract. It does not lower the price. It reduces the cash you bring to the table, which is often the real obstacle.
Take a $400,000 purchase with a 3% concession: that is $12,000 toward costs. Limits depend on loan type and down payment. Under the Fannie Mae Selling Guide’s interested-party contribution rules, a primary residence with a loan-to-value ratio above 90% has a 3% cap, with higher caps at lower LTVs. FHA and VA have their own limits, so check the current rules for your program, as they can change.
- Confirm the cap for your loan type with your broker.
- Have your agent write the concession into the offer as a dollar amount or percentage.
- Confirm the appraisal supports the contract price.
Two pitfalls come up often. The first is asking for more than the cap, or more than your actual costs, since concessions cannot produce cash back. The second is raising the offer price to pay for the concession. On the $400,000 example with 5% down, adding $12,000 to the price adds about $11,400 to the loan, roughly $72 a month at 6.5%, and the appraisal must still support the higher number. Measure your cash to close before and after the concession.
5. Take lender credits with a slightly higher rate
A lender credit is a payment the lender makes toward your costs in exchange for a higher interest rate. It shows up in Section J of the Loan Estimate as a reduction in total closing costs. Some borrowers ask about no-out-of-pocket closing options, and credits are how those are usually built. They are a trade, not a gift.
Here is an illustration with made-up pricing, not a quote. On a $350,000 30-year loan, a rate of 6.25% gives a principal and interest payment of about $2,155. A 6.75% rate with a $4,200 credit gives about $2,270, a difference near $115 a month. Divide $4,200 by $115 and you get a break-even of about 37 months. If you keep the loan ten years, you pay roughly $13,800 more in payments to save $4,200 up front.
- Ask for the same loan priced with a credit and without one.
- Find the credit in Section J and note the rate that comes with it.
- Divide the credit by the monthly payment difference to get break-even months.
The mistake is treating the credit as free money. It makes sense if you expect to sell or refinance before the break-even month, or if cash on hand matters more than long-run interest. Measure the break-even month against the time you realistically plan to keep the loan.
6. Buy down points only if break-even works
Discount points are fees you pay up front to lower your rate. They are the reverse of strategy 5, and the same break-even math decides whether they pay off. Points are not automatically a good deal, and many borrowers pay them and then move or refinance before the savings arrive.
Suppose you pay $6,000 in points and your payment drops by $110 a month. Divide $6,000 by $110 and break-even lands near month 55. If you sell in year four, you will have saved about $5,280 against $6,000 paid, a net loss of around $720. If you hold for twelve years, you come out well ahead.
- Ask for pricing at several point levels, including zero.
- For each, divide the points cost by the monthly savings.
- Compare that month against how long you will really hold the loan, allowing for a possible refinance if rates fall.
The pitfall is paying points on a loan you may refinance within a few years. Another is stretching your cash to buy points when that cash would cover a reserve fund. Measure break-even months against a realistic holding period, and be honest about that period. Most people move or refinance sooner than they expect.
7. Finance costs into the loan or use program features
Some programs let you add eligible costs to the loan balance instead of paying them at closing. Rules differ by program, so check the VA home loan pages and the HUD loan information for FHA before assuming a cost qualifies. The VA funding fee, for instance, can be financed under VA rules. Where eligible, a cash-out refinance to 90% can also cover costs from existing equity.
Imagine you finance $5,000 of refinance costs at 6.5% over 30 years. Your payment rises by about $32 a month. Across the full term that is roughly $11,400 in payments for $5,000 borrowed, so about $6,400 is interest. If you sell in five years, you will have paid about $1,900 of that and owe the rest in the balance.
- Ask your broker which costs can be financed on your loan type.
- Confirm the limits against the VA or HUD guidance for your program.
- Compare financing costs against paying them in cash or using a credit.
The mistake is forgetting that a financed amount is repaid with interest, and that a larger balance can affect your loan-to-value ratio. Measure the cash you save at closing against the added lifetime interest.
How the seven levers compare on cost, risk, and timing
Each strategy touches a different part of the Loan Estimate, so they behave differently. The dollar figures below come from the illustrations above, not from quotes.
| Strategy | Line it targets | Illustrated effect | Main risk | Best when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Line-by-line audit | Section A fees | $2,100 of overlapping fees questioned | Ignoring Section A | Always, first |
| Broker comparison | Section A plus rate | $1,800 spread in Section A | Unlike terms compared | Before any lock |
| Section C swap | Title and settlement | $450 saved | Off-list fees uncapped | Before closing |
| Seller concession | Cash to close | $12,000 on a $400,000 purchase | Program cap, appraisal | Purchases |
| Lender credit | Section J | $4,200 for about $115 a month | Break-even near month 37 | Short hold, low cash |
| Discount points | Rate | $110 a month for $6,000 | Break-even near month 55 | Long hold |
| Financing costs | Loan balance | About $32 a month on $5,000 | Repaid with interest | Tight cash at closing |
Questions borrowers ask about high closing costs
How much should closing costs be?
It depends on loan size, property type, location, and the loan program, so a single percentage is not reliable. Your own Loan Estimate is the better benchmark: compare Section J across two or three quotes on identical terms.
Can closing costs change after I get the Loan Estimate?
Some can, within limits. Lender fees generally cannot increase, certain third-party fees can rise by a combined 10%, and items like prepaid interest and escrow have no cap. The CFPB’s Loan Estimate guidance explains the tolerance buckets.
Are closing costs negotiable?
Many are. Section A fees can often be reduced or removed, Section C services can be shopped, and a seller can contribute within program caps. Government recording fees and taxes are not negotiable.
Are lender credits free money?
No. A credit is paid for with a higher interest rate, so you pay it back through your monthly payment. It is worth taking when you will leave the loan before the break-even month.
Do discount points always pay off?
No. Points pay off only if you keep the loan past the break-even month, which is points cost divided by monthly savings. Selling or refinancing earlier means you lose part of what you paid.
Does comparing quotes hurt my credit score?
A soft pull mortgage broker process does not. Duane Buziak uses No Touch Credit pre-qualification for a mortgage pre approval without hard pull, so you can compare options first. Scoring models also generally treat multiple mortgage inquiries within a short window as one, but confirm the details with a broker before a hard pull.
Is The Mortgage Ally by Duane Buziak affiliated with Ally Bank?
No. The Mortgage Ally by Duane Buziak is an independent mortgage broker service and has no affiliation with Ally Bank or Ally Financial. Duane Buziak is licensed in Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, and Georgia.
Can I roll closing costs into my loan?
Sometimes. Eligibility depends on whether you are buying or refinancing and on the program, so ask your broker and verify with VA or HUD guidance. Remember the financed amount accrues interest for the life of the loan.
Start with the free steps, then pick your trade-off
Begin with the two moves that cost nothing and carry no credit risk: audit your Loan Estimate line by line, then compare brokers on the same terms using a soft pull. Next, shop the Section C services, since a few phone calls can save hundreds. Only after that should you choose among credits, points, and concessions, and let the answer depend on how long you will keep the loan. A short hold favors credits and concessions, and a long hold favors points. If cash is the obstacle, financing eligible costs comes last because it carries interest.
Your dream home is within reach. Discover what hundreds of lenders can offer you in one simple search with zero impact to your credit score. Get your free mortgage rate quote today and let us shop the market to secure you the best possible terms with our client-first approach.



